High Court: (a) dismisses a couple's case arising from a dispute relating to the boundaries of their property, on the grounds that the proceedings were res judicata, frivolous and vexatious and an abuse of process in that the case was virtually identical to earlier High Court proceedings; and (b) grants a limited Isaac Wunder order against the couple restraining them from issuing proceedings relating to their previous litigation.
Interlocutory motion - defendants seeking to strike out the proceedings - inherent jurisdiction - frivolous vexatious and abuse of process - disclose no reasonable cause of action and/or that they are bound to fail - claims are res judicata - claims could have been brought forward in previous proceedings - seek an Isaac Wunder order - lay litigants assisted by McKenzie friends - procedural issues - purchase of lands - firm of solicitors represented both parties - question of the boundaries to the property - Circuit Court proceedings settled - did not accept settlement - plenary proceedings - dismissed by the High Court - valid agreement - did not appeal - defendants argued that new proceedings deal with all the same points - allegation of fraud - comparison of the pleadings - applicable legal principles - res judicata - present proceedings do not include a claim for the setting aside of that agreement - majority of the claims made relate to issues concerning title, ownership and boundary - High Court has determined that they are all matters covered by the settlement - all of the core issues raised in the current proceedings were dealt with in the 2004 proceedings - abuse of process/frivolous and vexatious claim - Henderson v. Henderson - clear public policy reasons why matters which have been substantially litigated or could and should have been substantially litigated in previous proceedings should not be permitted a rehearing - indicia of frivolous and vexatious litigation are present - virtually identical to the earlier High Court proceedings - an order restraining a party from issuing proceedings without leave of the court is an exceptional order to be made in rare circumstances - persistently instigated vexatious civil proceedings against these defendants - issued Isaac Wunder order - Order should be limited to the subject of the previous proceedings.