Clear and cogent reasons provided for refusing Pakistani national permission to reside

Judicial review – asylum and immigration – EU law - free movement of persons – Pakistani national challenging the review decision of the Minister for Justice refusing her a residence card – whether she is a permitted family member of her brother, a British national –first application made as a dependent of her sister in law - evidence of dependency – scant evidence - permission to reside refused – second application as a dependent member of her brother – application refused – insufficient evidence of dependence – review unsuccessful – relevant statutory provisions – alleged failure to give reasons/lack of clarity - onus was on the Pakistani national to satisfy the Minister by cogent evidence that was in part documented and could be tested - provided little or no information about her personal or family circumstances - evidence was not sufficient to establish the dependency - Minister provided clear and cogent reasons for the decision on review to confirm the decision not to grant a residence card – judicial review refused.