High Court, in negligence and breach of contract proceedings, refuses defendant's application to dismiss proceedings for want of prosecution/inordinate and inexcusable delay, on the grounds that, notwithstanding the fact that five years have passed since the issuance of the proceedings (which period is both inordinate and inexcusable), the balance of justice favours the continuation of the proceedings where the plaintiffs' financial and familial difficulties during that period disabled them from instructing solicitors and progressing the matter, and where the defendant has contributed to the delay by failing, as yet, to deliver its defence.
Application to dismiss proceedings for want of prosecution - inordinate and inexcusable delay - proceedings seeking damages for negligence and breach of contract arising from alleged defects in the design of plaintiff's family home - statement of claim delivered in July 2012 - proceedings against second defendant dismissed by the High Court (Kearns P) as defendant not properly incorporated as of the date of a retainer/construction - solicitors only came on record for plaintiffs following the issuance of dismissal proceedings in late 2016/early 2017 - plaintiff allege financial and familial difficulties prevented them from instructing solicitors and progressing their case - jurisprudence on dismissing actions - concepts of fairness and justice - balancing of interests - case law to be considered on such an application - defendant yet to deliver defence - inordinate delay accepted by plaintiff - no explanation provided for how plaintiff's financial circumstances led to such inordinate delay or how they were able to instruct solicitors within a month of the defendant issuing this motion - plaintiffs intend to rely on conversations held between parties in 1999 - timeline of events - defendant a clear recollection of events - period since issuance of statement of claim - defendant's own delay in progressing matter - clearly excusable delay on plaintiffs' part - balance of justice - basic fairness and procedures - plaintiffs to be permitted to continue their claims.