Minister correct in determining that non-national’s EU spouse was required to have sufficient resources in his application for residence card

Judicial review – asylum and immigration – European law – free movement of persons – challenge to the decision refusing application for a permanent residence card - married a Czech national – no longer in contact – claims that he and his wife were lawfully resident in Ireland pursuant to reg.6 of the EC (Free Movement of Persons) Regulations 2015 for five years prior to her departure - breach of the right to fair procedures – claims that the Minister raised for the first time in his review decision an issue about the details of residence of his wife Czech spouse in Ireland – in fact raised before - claims that the Minister was mistaken in asserting in the Impugned Decision that his spouse required to be employed/self-employed or to have sufficient resources and comprehensive sickness insurance in circumstances where he was economically active - Minister was not mistaken - sufficient resources - mere fact that the non-EU national is working does not suffice to meet the requirements of the statute – judicial review refused.