Minister erred in law in refusing Bangladeshi brother a visa as a dependent of UK citizen brother

Asylum and immigration – judicial review – applicant originally from Bangladesh – naturalised UK citizen – exercising free movement of persons rights to work and live in Ireland – brother, a Bangladeshi national, claims to be dependent on him in England– Minister refused application for Bangladeshi national to travel and live with his UK brother in this State as a dependent member of his family – errors by both parties – whether the Minister erred in his application of the relevant provisions of the EC (Free Movement of Persons) Regulations 2015 - Minister erred in law in identifying a deficiency of documentation provided in respect of matters that did not properly arise for consideration – whether the Minister acted unreasonably and/or in breach of EU law and/or the 2015 Regulations in determining that the Bangladeshi brother had failed to provide sufficient evidence that he was a member of his brother’s household - abundance of evidence – meaning of “household” – Minister in his reasoning fails to have regard to the full meaning of household - Minister acted unreasonably and/or in breach of fair procedures in concluding that the Bangladeshi brother had failed to submit satisfactory evidence that he was a dependent of the UK brother and/or a member of his household, without adopting procedures which would have enabled the Bangladeshi brother to know what evidence he was required to adduce in order to establish same – whether the Minister acted in breach of fair procedures and/or natural and constitutional justice by refusing the Bangladeshi brother’s application on the basis of matters which were never put to him – judicial review granted.