Non-EU citizen’s application for residence card correctly refused where no evidence of dependency

Asylum and immigration – judicial review – EU national with a non-EU citizen stepdaughter challenging the decision of the Minister for Justice and Equality refusing review of decision refusing her a residence card – chronology of events – previous judicial review proceedings moot - review application failed because no evidence of the stepdaughter’s dependency in the third country state was provided - complains that no such evidence was sought – Minister repeatedly sought the information - the need for material support must exist in the State of origin or the State from which they came when they applied to join the Community national - presumed to know that when evidence of dependency is sought it is evidence of the type identified in Jia/Reyes that is being sought - court assumes in passing that in seeking further evidence of dependency the Minister was not concealing from him that what was being sought was evidence of the type identified in Jia/Reyes – no evidence of concealment – judicial review refused –