High Court, in personal injuries proceedings, dismisses claim for damages arising from alleged injuries caused to plaintiff arising from a fall from a bicycle during a holiday abroad in 1998, on the grounds that due to a delay of 19 years, a medical doctor is now deceased and instructors (as witnesses for the defendant) cannot be traced, and a fair trial cannot now take place owing to the prejudice which has demonstrably been suffered by the defendant in the intervening time.
Personal injuries - application to dismiss plaintiff's claim on grounds of delay - inherent jurisdiction of the court - injuries from fall off bicycle during package holiday in 1998 - proceedings issued in August 1999 - chronology of proceedings appended to judgment - review of replies to particulars by plaintiff in September 2003 - notice of intention to proceed in 2013, 2014 & 2015 - notice of trial served in March 2016 - no excuse or explanation offered for plaintiff's delay - general prejudice - medical doctor is now deceased - witnesses cannot be tracked - whether central issue is in fact the supply of an unsafe bicycle to the plaintiff - balance of justice - whether a fair trial can now take place - no prospect that witnesses will recall event - hearsay evidence of contemporaneous conversation between plaintiff and doctor in immediate aftermath of injuries is unavailable - issue of liability - allegation of improper instruction on use of bicycle can only now be given by the instructors themselves - whether defendant's acquiescence disentitles it to order sought - defendant entitled to await service of notice of trial prior to issuing motion to dismiss - fair trial now not possible given lapse of time - claim dismissed.