High Court grants summary judgment enforcing a conciliator's recommendation in respect of a construction contract dispute arising from an agreement, entered into between the parties, to carry out of paving and other works, on the grounds that, although the award may later be amended or rejected by an arbitrator, the contractual agreement entered into permits the conciliator's recommendation to become binding pending any arbitration proceedings later taking place on the completion of certain conditions precedent by the plaintiff, and there is no dispute that these were in fact adhered to.
Summary judgment - enforcement of a conciliator's recommendation - prior refusal to stay proceedings pursuant to Model Law - Article 8 - paving and works contracts providing for arbitration, but conciliation at first instance - conditions precedent to payment of money following conciliator's recommendation complied with by plaintiff - suitable bond provided - 'same dispute' defence - whether plaintiff sought to introduce additional claims in its 'notice to refer' after conciliator's recommendation - 'clause 12' defence - subcontract terminated by defendants upon alleged default by plaintiff - jurisprudence on application for summary judgment - different test given the circumstances of dispute - whether defendants meet threshold required for the issue of payment of the conciliator's recommendation to be remitted for plenary hearing - defendant served a notice of dissatisfaction with recommendation within allotted time - whether sum must be paid pending arbitration - sum may be later varied by arbitrator - matters before conciliator and arbitrator are, in fact, the 'same dispute' by virtue of decision of conciliator - clauses of subcontract do not preclude conciliator from considering plaintiff's claim and making a recommendation - conciliator aware of defendant's arguments on termination - no submission made to conciliator that it was unable to make recommendation in favour of plaintiff by virtue of sub-clause - monies due and now secured by bond - judgment will not encroach on role of arbitrator - obligation to pay is binding because of the agreement in place between parties - no bona fide defence established - plaintiff entitled to judgment.