Supreme Court, in appeal brought by mortgagor against order of the High Court (Dunne J) granting well charging orders in respect of a judgment mortgage registered over certain lands in Cork, amends the proceedings to include claim in respect of specific folio wrongly deleted from special summons grounding the proceedings but dismisses appeal as appellant has no defence to various orders made by the High Court.
O'Donnell J (nem diss): Appeal against High Court decision granting well-charging orders on foot of a judgment mortgage obtained by the respondents in the sum of €621,779.30 - stay refused - lands in County Cork - well-charging order of certain lands not contested but claim in respect of specific folio reinstated following written judgment of High Court - appellant alleged the existence of a prior charge in favour of his daughter, with the result that the requisite special summons was not properly before the court - Order of Master of High Court deleting said folio from special summons acknowledged subsequently by plaintiff/respondent to be a misstep - application brought by plaintiff/respondent subsequently to vacate prior order - whether court should allow appeal with result that further identical proceedings should be instituted in respect of specific folio to cure prior defect in procedure - appeal of no practical benefit to appellant - whether result would result in costs implications in favour of appellant - order of High court vacated and claim in respect of specific folio re-instated as no question of prejudice suffered by appellant - balance of justice lay in favour of plaintiffs - well-charging order perfected - order of Supreme Court granting extension of time to appeal - Ord. 26, r. 1 RSC - whether High Court order should stand in circumstances where a precedent allegedly relied on had been overruled - whether order of Master of High Court represented a de facto notice of discontinuance as a matter of law - High Court retained jurisdiction to amend and subsequently re-amend its Order - court orders amendment of proceedings to include specific folio - appellant has no defence to well charging and ancillary orders made in High Court - appeal dismissed.